Hiring an Unregistered Contractor in Massachusetts: What You Give Up

Short answer: In Massachusetts, two different things get called “licensed”: a home improvement contractor (HIC) registration under M.G.L. chapter 142A, and a construction supervisor license (CSL) under 780 CMR 110.R5. Insurance is a third, separate question. A contractor can have one and not the others. If the person you hire has no HIC registration, the law’s safety nets for owners are written for registered contractors: the state’s Guaranty Fund and its arbitration program. A license holder who answers for the work on the permit is a separate piece, and it depends on who pulls the permit. This article is about what you give up. If you have not yet checked anyone, start with how to check a Massachusetts home improvement contractor before you sign.

This is general information from the text of the law, not legal advice. The statute and regulation are quoted where possible, and the current text is the one that counts.

The Guaranty Fund is written for registered contractors

Chapter 142A, section 5 creates the Residential Contractor’s Guaranty Fund “to compensate owners for actual losses incurred by them as a result of registered contractor or subcontractor conduct” that a court or an arbitrator has found to be poor or unworkmanlike work, a common-law violation, or a violation of a consumer-protection statute or regulation. The words that matter are “registered contractor.”

Section 13 puts the warning on the permit itself: “All building permits shall clearly state that persons contracting with unregistered contractors do not have access to the guaranty fund under this chapter.”

Even with a registered contractor, the fund is the last stop, not the first. Section 7 says:

  • You need a judgment or an arbitration award, and the claim has to be filed “not more than 7 years from the date of the contract.”
  • The contractor must have failed to pay, and the state must have decided that reasonable efforts to collect have been made.
  • The fund may not award “more than $25,000 or any amount necessary to compensate the owner for his actual loss, whichever is less to any one claimant.”
  • It may not award consequential damages (with one exception), or anything for personal injury, punitive damages, attorney’s fees, court costs or interest.

Section 2 adds a related rule that is easy to miss. The contract has to say that “homeowners who secure their own permits will be excluded from the guaranty fund provisions.” Pulling the permit yourself to speed things up has the same effect as hiring someone unregistered: you step outside the fund.

The arbitration program is described for registered contractors too

Section 4 sets up a private arbitration program “to consider disputes between owners and registered contractors and subcontractors,” and says no claim may be filed “after 5 years from the date of the contract.” An owner can ask for it under section 3(b). Again, the statute describes it in terms of registered contractors.

Courts are a separate route. Section 3(a) lets any party bring an action “to enforce any provision of this chapter” in the superior court, the district court or the small claims division. Section 17 lists operating “without a certificate of registration” as a prohibited act, and says violations of the chapter “shall constitute an unfair or deceptive act” under chapter 93A. So the law does not close the courthouse to you. What you lose is the backstop if the person cannot or will not pay. How any of this applies to your case is a question for a lawyer.

Registration and the CSL are two different things

People say “he’s licensed” and mean either one. They come from different offices under different rules.

  • HIC registration comes from the state’s Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation under chapter 142A. Section 9 says no contractor may “undertake, offer to undertake, or agree to perform residential contracting services unless registered.” Section 13 requires the registration number on every contract, building permit and advertisement. Under section 11 the certificate “shall not be transferable,” so the name on the contract should be the name on the registration. Section 17 also prohibits “conducting a residential contracting business in any name other than the one in which the contractor or subcontractor is registered.”
  • CSL comes from the Board of Building Regulations and Standards under 780 CMR 110.R5. A construction supervisor is “a person of good moral character who is deemed qualified by the BBRS to directly supervise persons engaged in” construction work, and anyone supervising work regulated by the building code must be licensed, with listed exceptions. In general, a candidate needs at least three years of experience and has to pass an exam. The BBRS keeps a list of licensees that is available to the public.

One does not stand in for the other. Section 14 lists people who do not need to register, including licensed electricians and plumbers working only within their trade, and then adds “construction supervisors excepted.” So a CSL does not by itself exempt someone from registering. If anyone tells you they are exempt, ask the state; do not take it on trust.

Whose license is on the permit

Under 780 CMR 110.R5.2.16, a building permit application has to contain “the name, signature and license number and the category of license so held of the construction supervisor who is to supervise those persons engaged in the work.” If that person stops supervising, “the work shall immediately cease until a successor license holder is substituted.”

That name carries responsibility. The regulation says the license holder “shall be fully and completely responsible for all work for which he or she is supervising.” The same regulation requires a licensed supervisor or designee to be on site at certain points, which include installing structural members, insulation and air barriers, and smoke and carbon monoxide detectors.

If something goes wrong, anyone can file a complaint with the BBRS. For a complaint about the agreement or the code compliance of the work, the deadline is three years from the agreement or from the last work, whichever is later. The outcomes the regulation lists are a reprimand, a suspension or a revocation of the license, and the hearings officer may also order the license holder to retake the CSL exam. Those concern the license; paying you back is not on that list. That is another reason the fund and the courts matter.

There is a homeowner route. For a one- or two-family home, a homeowner doing permitted work is exempt from the CSL requirement, “provided that if a homeowner engages a person(s) for hire to do such work, then such homeowner shall act as supervisor.” If a contractor suggests you pull the permit, the regulation makes you the supervisor for the people you hire, and you are outside the fund.

Insurance is a separate question

In the sections of chapter 142A on registration, contracts, the fund and penalties, insurance is not mentioned. So a registration number is not proof that anyone is insured. Under chapter 152, section 25A, “every employer shall provide for the payment to his employees of the compensation provided for by this chapter,” by insurance, by membership in a self-insurance group, or by a self-insurer license from the state.

Ask for a certificate of workers’ compensation insurance and a certificate of liability insurance, with the policy dates, and have your contractor’s insurance agent send them to you directly. What happens if an uninsured worker is hurt on your property, or damage is not covered, depends on the facts. We are not lawyers, so ask your own insurance agent or attorney before the work starts.

Sun Shore Construction is licensed and insured, and proof is available on request.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • What is your HIC registration number, and is the name on it the name on this contract?
  • Who holds the construction supervisor license for this job, and will that name be on the permit application?
  • Will the license holder or a licensed designee be on site at the inspection points?
  • Who pulls the permit, and does the contract say so?
  • Can you have your insurance agent send me the certificates, with dates?
  • How are disputes handled, and is any arbitration clause written out and signed separately?

Checklist

  • Registration number looked up with the state; name matches the contract
  • CSL holder named, and the same name on the permit application
  • Permit pulled by the contractor, not by you
  • Certificates of insurance in hand, sent by the agent, dates checked
  • Contract in writing, with no blank spaces

FAQ

Can I still take an unregistered contractor to court? Section 3(a) lets any party bring an action to enforce the chapter in court, and section 17 says violations are unfair or deceptive acts under chapter 93A. What you do not get is the Guaranty Fund. A lawyer can tell you what applies to your situation.

Does the Guaranty Fund pay for everything that goes wrong? No. It needs a judgment or award, an unpaid contractor and a collection effort. The statute caps it per owner and excludes things like attorney’s fees and interest.

Is a CSL the same as an HIC registration? No. They come from different offices under different rules, and section 14 specifically says construction supervisors are not exempt from registering.

What about small jobs? Section 14 lists exemptions, for example for contractors who work exclusively in certain areas such as landscaping, interior painting or finished floor covering. A full remodel involves more than one of those. If someone says they are exempt, ask the state.

Eric Zhang is the owner of Sun Shore Construction, a general contractor in Greater Boston founded in 2020. He has more than a decade of hands-on renovation experience.

Planning a bathroom remodel? Get a free in-home estimate: call us or fill out the form on sunshoreconstruction.com.

Language »
(857) 858-2600 Call Now Free Estimate